My favourite PreCure era is approximately its first decade and this is an "everyone's grown up" reunion series for the franchise's first five years' worth of heroines, so of course I was going to watch it. Guaranteed. Not up for debate. Would the series be half-arsed modern PreCure that didn't bother with drama, plot, etc.? Maybe. That wouldn't stop me. I would watch this show even if I hated it, because I love its heroines. They are:
Futari wa PreCure! (years 1-2) = Honoka and Nagisa only get a cameo right at the end, but they're the ones I'd been waiting for. They're the originals. The definitive, mandatory PreCures. If they hadn't appeared, I'd have screamed blue murder.
Futari wa PreCure Splash Star (year 3) = Saki Hyuga and Mai Mishou are only second-string leads here, but I'm still impressed to see that they're important supporting players. I'm pleased and surprised to see them again. Splash Star was darker, mature and had some of the franchise's most memorable drama, but it's underrated because it's such obvious self-plagiarism. Its replacement protagonists are Honoka and Nagisa clones, both in appearance (identical faces, although with different hairstyles) and personality (tomboy vs. girlier girl, although they soon became distinctive in their own right). Even the title's still "Futari wa PreCure (something)".
This was a mistake. Saki and Mai will always be overshadowed in popular memory and even lack presence in team-up movies. This is the forgotten PreCure season... but it deserved better.
What's more, we even meet Kaoru and Michiru, which is "scream and punch the air" time. Those villains had a complicated relationship with our heroines and ended up becoming PreCures themselves. They're the best thing in Splash Star and it's an outrage that they've generally been overlooked in team-up movies. They're relatively minor players here, but I love them and they're still weirdos.
Yes! PreCure 5 (years 4-5) = that's Nozomi and her friends... and Nozomi's the main character here. We even meet Bunbee! Awesome. He's probably my favourite male character in the franchise. Like Kaoru and Michiru, he's a villain who ended up helping the PreCures... but he's simpler, funnier and less emotionally resonant than them. He was just a punch-card villain who was out to make a bit of cash and kept encountering comedy butt-monkey fates. Nothing could keep him down. He tried to make himself the PreCures' manager. This series is again taking the opportunity to resurrect classic characters who were among my favourite PreCure supporting stars but haven't been mentioned in years.
There's nothing particularly surprising in this revival's scripts. It has monsters of the week. They're called Shadows and they're a generic PreCure handwave. This might be the first PreCure show for adults, but it's still sticking to the formulae. The Shadows' boss is worried about the environment, though, giving the show a message.
Who will fight the Shadows? Our heroines have grown up, so they can drink beer, have obnoxious bosses and perhaps get married. (If they're lucky.) However, they can't transform into PreCures... until Nozomi discovers that she can after all. Why? What was this rule? What was the point of it? No idea. Does it matter? Her friends might possibly be able to as well.
Anyway, hurrah! Fight! Transformations will take a physical toll, but will this stop our heroines? Do you need to ask? This is the infinitely optimistic idiot Nozomi we're talking about.
This show is neither good nor bad. It's a decent enough reunion that manages to avoid being Empty Modern Garbage, but it's doing nothing you won't see coming. I love it for its cast. Seeing these old friends is wonderful. If you've watched the first five years of PreCure (which is admittedly a lot of television), this sequel is mandatory. If you haven't, it's probably not worth bothering with... but at least the show has a point. It's talking about what it means to have grown up and got stuck with awkward jobs, personal circumstances, etc. Sometimes this hiccups forth an interesting episode. Rin's examination in episode 6 is reasonably good. I also liked the environmental message, which targets the all-too-common position of "yes, it's bad, yes, I care, but it's nothing to do with me because there's no way I can affect anything that big". (The show's take on this is obvious, but wholehearted.)
This isn't the show I'd have chosen to make, but it's been years since I expected this franchise to do anything brave. It's too big. Compare this forgettable series with Yatterman Night or Gatchaman Crowds (although the latter doesn't overlap much with the original Gatchaman). This was the first adult PreCure sequel and it's a bit of a mess, but it did well enough to encourage Toei to try again two years later and occasionally learn from their mistakes. The plot's unimaginative, there are too many protagonists and the theme of "adult life isn't as simple as we thought" is passable but a bit obvious. I'm also not wild about the girls having lost their transformation abilities, especially given how it immediately gets fudged with "I can't transform any more, yes I can but I'm now fourteen years old again, no I can't, etc."
I enjoyed it, though. I love its heroines and it was successful enough to get a greenlight for Maho Girls Pretty Cure!! MIRAI DAYS. I've watched that too, obviously, and I'll review it tomorrow. I'm not sure why they're avoiding HeartCatch PreCure, but maybe they're holding back for a hypothetical future date when Toei's allowed PreCure to get good again?