It's Toei's second adult PreCure sequel series, after 2023's
Power of Hope: PreCure Full Bloom. Have Toei learned from their mistakes and worked out how to make a good show? Ahahahahaha, I wouldn't go that far. Again, though, I had a ton of goodwill from my memories of the original 2016 series (even though that had turned to garbage halfway through) and again I enjoyed this modern sequel.
I love how faithful it is (including the Harry Potter rip-offs). There's a lesson here for anyone who thinks you have to "improve" on everything when making a sequel. This is absolutely 100% the world of the 2016
Mahoutsukai PreCure!, with the magical world's inhabitants not always even having aged. Are they immortal? It's possible. Hell, this series even gives a cameo to someone from the 2016 All-Stars movie (Solciere from
Pretty Cure All Stars: Singing with Everyone Miraculous Magic!). It nails all the details, which is all-important since neither the original nor this sequel is objectively anything special. That nostalgia hit is its most important weapon. I didn't so much watch this show as mainline it. I particularly love the fact their use of the original theme song. Iconic theme music is at the heart of PreCure.
It's clearly an improvement on where the original Mahoutsukai left off. In retrospect, it's a fix. Anyone rewatching the two together will see a V-shaped gradient of "strong and likeable" (2013 first half) + "barely watchable" (2013 second half) + "perfectly decent university-age sequel" (2025).
It's worth comparing this with PreCure Full Bloom. Have they fixed its problems? 1. "Way too many heroines" = yup, that's resolved. The focus is entirely on Mahoutsukai, which itself had had a fairly tight cast. 2. "We can't transform into PreCures any more, whoops, actually we can with a weird dual-age contrivance" = yup, someone did the right thing and said "bugger all that". Mirai and Riko have grown up, there's nothing mysterious about their age and they can transform just fine. 3. "Story, what story?" = well, sort of. We have a two-stage season arc, with different villains. Unfortunately, one's better than the other.
1. IRE is clever, mysterious and might occasionally make you wonder if he's breaking the fourth wall. He can predict the future, but he has mother issues. Mum told him that he couldn't use magic, but she supported him in her own way and she's dead now. He's a villain worth watching and I enjoyed the disagreements between our heroines vowing to change the future vs. Ire insisting that that's impossible.
2. TIME BEAST CHRONOSTO is amusing ("woof") but that's it. He's a generic Doomsday Villain and less interesting than Ire... but he supplies light comedy and I liked his big fight in episode 11. I didn't hate him. We've seen worse. He also continues the series's time travel theme.
I enjoyed this series. That's nostalgia-fuelled, obviously, but even so I like the happy friends-together ending and its existence rescues the original series. It pulls Mahoutsukai out of the toilet it had flushed itself down in 2013. It also has a distinctive premise, being a cross-fertilisation of the massive PreCure franchise with Harry Potter plagiarism, a decent look at time travel and of course the adventures of witch-on-a-broomstick heroines who moonlight as superheroes when no one's watching. It also made me laugh. It should be mandatory viewing for anyone who stuck with Mahoutsukai PreCure to the end, at least.